Cathode Tan - Games, Media and Geek Stuff
logo design by man bytes blog

Monday, November 28, 2005

Thompson Heads To Tennessee

Actually, I'm not sure he is physically going there, but his continuing crusade to find a legal case which is actually winnable heads off to Tennessee, where he once again blames Grand Theft Auto for training a violent teenager:

This is how lousy Jack is at his job:

Now well-known Florida Lawyer Jack Thompson, who previously linked Rockstar game Manhunt to the murder of 14-year-old Stefan Pakeerah in Leicester last year, has reportedly said teenager Ken Bartley Jr, who shot three high school staff in Tennessee earlier this month, was trained to kill by Grand Theft Auto.

...

In a statement, the lawyer said: "As has happened in other instances, as in the triple homicide in Fayette, Alabama, by an 18-year-old obsessive player of the cop-killing Grand Theft Auto: Vice City, a highly-charged emotional event can serve as a trigger for such a shooting."
-- City-designed violent video game blamed for US murder

What's interesting about those two sections of the article? Well, in the first one ... the connection between the kid and the video game was dismissed because it was the victim who was a fan of the game, not the killer (and the police never took the link seriously) ... and in the second one Thompson was forcibly removed from the case and then had his temporary Alabama legal license revoked ... largely because he would do things like call the family of the killer and suggest publically that it was factually sound that their child was brainwashed by a video game.

Any betting man knows how this one will go. Media will make frenzy out of nothing, eventually rational people will look at the evidence and realize how crazy it really is and then the whole thing will get laughed out of court.

In other words, Jack Thompson is becoming a professional failure.



tagged: , ,

1 comment:

Josh said...

For the BatJack Hunters out there, I sent this to the Scotsman:

Regarding:
http://edinburghnews.scotsman.com/index.cfm?id=2307772005

Your story on the Tennessee shooter being linked to
video game fails to mention a few truths to balance the content, making it somewhat misleading and inaccurate.

This quote:

"Now well-known Florida Lawyer Jack Thompson, who previously linked Rockstar game Manhunt to the murder of 14-year-old Stefan Pakeerah in Leicester last year"

Fails to mention that the link was never an official part of the police investigation, resulted in a failed lawsuit, and that the victim ... not the killer ... was the player of the game.

So in reality, Thompson failed to make such a link.

And this point:

"n a statement, the lawyer said: "As has happened in other instances, as in the triple homicide in Fayette, Alabama, by an 18-year-old obsessive player of the cop-killing Grand Theft Auto: Vice City, a highly-charged emotional event can serve as a trigger for such a shooting.""

Fails to point out that Thompson has been forcibly removed from that case for his outrageous public behavior and tendency to make such inaccurate and unproven links in a public forum.

Without this information, this story borders on sensationalism rather than journalism. I hope that your paper would avoid such problems in the future.

You can do the same here:
http://members.scotsman.com/contact.cfm